Historically Tidewater Sandals have run small, however we have made efforts to adjust our fit to align with standard sizing. Please order your true size. If you are a half size or have a wide foot, we recommend sizing up.

Please note, due to the handmade nature of our product and differences between materials, some styles may fit slightly snugger at first. Rest assured, they will loosen up to become a perfect fit as your foot molds to the our proprietary EVA footbed.

Though we don’t offer wide or narrow fit specifically on any of our styles, if your foot is on the wider size we recommend choosing from our Everyday Flip Flop collection. If your foot is more narrow, our Premium Flip Flops might be the better option for you!

Our Nantucket style (the light tan bottom with the rope style) and slide styles have a more narrow footbed. It's very comfortable and offers premium arch support with metatarsal pads, but we do recommend sizing up if you have a wider foot.